
We ordered two pairs of this printed short through our agent: green in size L and black in 3XL. Both went on the bench in Rotterdam and were opened in front of two editors before anything was measured. The brief was narrow, because the listing does not publish a flat size chart. We wanted to know whether the M–5XL ladder is graded consistently from size to size, and whether "stain-resistant" means anything on a polyester short selling at $5.22.
Both pairs arrived in plain poly bags with no hangtag and no brand marking on the care label. The Celine name exists in the listing title and in the monogram-style motif printed on the fabric; nothing in the parcel labels the garment. That is worth stating plainly before the measurements, because it frames what this item is: a $5.22 summer short with a designer-referencing print, described by the seller as polyester with breathable, machine-washable, wrinkle-resistant, stain-resistant and colourfast properties.
The size ladder: 4 cm a step, measured twice
With no published chart, the only honest way to test sizing was to buy two sizes and measure the difference between them. We laid both pairs flat, measured the same points twice with a steel tape, and recorded the delta per step rather than a single pair's numbers. Two steps separate L and 3XL.
| Measurement (flat, cm) | L, green | 3XL, black | Delta per size step |
|---|---|---|---|
| Waist, relaxed | 37.0 | 45.0 | 4.0 |
| Waist, at working drawstring tension | 42.5 | 50.0 | 3.75 |
| Hip, 20 cm below waist | 54.0 | 62.5 | 4.25 |
| Outseam | 45.5 | 47.5 | 1.0 |
| Inseam | 15.0 | 15.0 | 0 |
| Leg opening | 31.0 | 34.0 | 1.5 |
| Waistband depth | 4.0 | 4.0 | 0 |
The grade holds. Body width moves about 4 cm per size, which is what a straight-leg cargo cut should do, and length barely changes — the 3XL is only 2 cm longer in the outseam. That is good news for shorter buyers going up a size for waist room, and mildly bad news for taller ones, who should not expect the extra length a two-size jump usually buys.
Two things to plan around. First, the listing allows a 1–2 cm measurement tolerance, and a 4 cm grade is comfortably outside it, so sizing up moves you further than the seller's own error margin — you cannot rely on tolerance to close a fit gap. Second, the low-rise waist with no belt loops means the drawstring is the entire fit system; there is no belt to rescue a waist that sits loose. Our advice is to measure a pair of shorts you already own flat across the waist and buy the size closest to that number, not to the size on your usual jeans.
"The chart tells you nothing, so the grade has to: about 4 cm of body width per size, and almost no extra length."
Two drops against the stain-resistant claim
The listing claims stain resistance and colourfastness. We put two controlled drops on the green pair while it lay flat on the bench, photographed each at 0 and 10 minutes, then washed the pair at 30 °C.
- Water: the drop sat proud for roughly 20 seconds, then wet out into a darker patch and spread to about 3 cm. It dried without a tide mark. This is not a repellent finish; there is no DWR-style beading.
- Olive oil: the drop held its shape and darkened the polyester immediately. A dry paper towel lifted the surface film but left a visible shadow. One 30 °C machine wash with regular detergent removed most of it; a faint ring was still findable on the green ground under a light, and gone after a second wash.
So "stain-resistant" is closer to "forgiving of spills you blot promptly" than to a coated, wipe-clean fabric. Grease needs detergent and a second cycle. Water-based marks, coffee rings and dust rinse out easily, which is the realistic use case for a $5.22 short.
Drawstring and hardware, calipers out
Hardware gets measured, not eyeballed. The cord is a braided polyester round cord at 3.2 mm on the calipers, with roughly 41 cm of free end on each side and a single heat-sealed tip per end — no metal aglets, no toggle. It threads through two bartacked eyelets in the 4 cm waistband and ties in a plain bow.
Under a 30-minute walk with a loaded tote and a ten-minute stair climb, the bow held without a double knot, and the cord showed no fraying at the tips after two washes and a tumble on low. The stretch in the waistband is modest — we recorded about 5 cm of give at comfortable tension — so the drawstring adjusts fit rather than creating it. If the relaxed waist is too big for you, cinching will pucker the front but will not pull the hip in.
Print, seams and the listing's conflicting pattern field
The listing's own pattern field says solid colour while the title says all-over print, and the compiled listing notes flag that mismatch. Both pairs we received are printed: a repeating light monogram-style motif on a green or black ground, with a solid waistband and matching tie. Under an 8× loupe the ink sits on the surface of the weave rather than penetrating it, which is normal for cheap polyester and the reason we watched the wash cycles closely — after two 30 °C washes at low tumble, the print showed no cracking or lifting and the green lost no visible depth.
Side-seam continuity is decent on our green L, with the motif running through the seam within a few millimetres. Our black 3XL drifted more, close to half a centimetre, enough to catch at a glance if you look for it. Buyers who need the print to line up exactly across both legs should ask the agent for flat photos of the specific pair being shipped, since this varies unit to unit.
How it scored
The 4.2 / 5 reflects a genuinely useful summer short at a very low price: the size ladder is graded properly, the print survives washing, the cord is finished rather than fraying, and the polyester is light and quick to dry. It loses points for the missing flat chart — which forces buyers into guesswork the seller could remove with one table — for a stain-resistance claim that only holds for water-based marks, and for a low-rise, beltless waist that leaves no room for error.
Product details as listed: SKU 7717465313, $5.22 USD, marked down from $5.96, in stock, sizes M through 5XL in apricot, black and green. The listing states a standard thickness, slight stretch and a 1–2 cm measurement tolerance, all of which matched what we handled. What we cannot confirm is durability past two washes, long-term print behaviour on a $5.22 polyester, or anything about the item's provenance beyond the listing's own description.